But the asset managers will receive a bonus if the properties are sold within a year, thereby putting pressure on them to discourage appraisals considered high enough to block quick sales. The Act requires lenders, mortgage brokers, or servicers of home loans to provide borrowers with pertinent and timely disclosures regarding the nature and costs of the real estate . The most influential measure was the Dodd-Frank Wall Street Reform and Consumer Protection Act, which introduced steps designed to regulate the financial sector's activities and protect consumers . Its unclear how many of those cases were referred to related licensing boards for review. These regulatory structures address multi-state licensing through technology or a common licensing platform. ''There is definite pressure to keep values low,'' said Scruggs Love Jr., president of the American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, the nation's largest organization of appraisers who work on commercial real estate deals. Whats the Next Wave in Oversight for Real Estate Appraisers? The lender wants to ensure the amount of money being loaned isn't more than the property is worth. requirement (56%). The appraisal industry continues to be criticized for racially based bias against Black homeowners . In addition, the Appraisal Standards Board published the most recent version of USPAP in January 2014, with the next revision to become effective January 1, 2016. rule stated that an increase would be appropriate given the increases in real hb```f``f`2^01 P( a?+X2_V0{kn iv;rZqa+s Pc2 -@dSg]z[1064,=W%.gIn f. First Came FIRREA, then Dodd-Frank. Appraisers inspect the property's features and compare it to similar properties to determine its value. Certain home sales of $400,000 and under will soon not need an appraisal, after federal regulators approved a proposal to increase the threshold at which residential home sales require an . As comprehensive as it is, the Dodd-Frank Act introduced minimal changes in the oversight of real property valuations. received suggested that evaluations are appropriate substitutes for appraisals Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window), Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window), Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window), Despite new rules, appraisers say pressure remains, Florida Department of Business and Professional Regulation, Public Integrity acquires tool to make data more accessible to journalists, Public Integrity staff share expertise in using data to cover inequality, Funding decisions often shortchange homeless students, Creative Commons Attribution-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License, Proudly powered by Newspack by Automattic. It indicates a possible lack of ethical standards, Clark said. Congress hopes to supplant the appraisal governing body at the center of the industrys self-regulated framework and make public the trove of appraisal data held by the government-sponsored enterprises. `"o[Z:7|~~~G} -}7W\Ev} Mr,$VqLZ2$'fm%VGCx/j>. And then along came the mortgage market meltdown of 2008. The appraisal threshold was last increased in 1994 when regulators approved an increase from $100,000 to $250,000. Regulations of the Real Estate Commissioner. Thus, through the common law, state law, and the Constitution, they . Anyone can read what you share. Congressional investigators, after reviewing records of failed savings and loans, found that more than 8 in 10 had glaring errors in appraisals on their books. Critics say many appraisal mistakes of the 80's were based on comparable sales analysis. Gluck surrendered his appraisal license in 2007 following charges that he prepared two inaccurate, misleading, and deficient appraisals and, more seriously, that he falsely certified that he had no financial interest in properties he appraised. Although many appraisers are highly trained, they say a lack of uniform standards, combined with the rush atmosphere of the 80's, drew into the field many with little or no experience. ''It was common practice,'' Mr. Bunton said. Appraisals are traditionally used in real estate transactions and are common in refinancing a home loan. Arizona Board of Appraisal. Business and Professions Code Sections 10000 through 11288. Woolf described his former apprentice as a middle-aged man who bristled under his oversight, often performing incomplete and inaccurate appraisals. Woolf never worked that far north on Floridas Atlantic coast. Using advanced technology, the analysts at Fannie Mae have been able to develop a comprehensive risk management tool, and on January 26, 2015, Fannie Mae released the Collateral Underwriter making it available to Fannie Maes Corresponding Lenders. The former appraiser is now listed as the administrator of Integrity Appraisal Management, Inc., an appraisal management company in El Monte, California. H*:lSw[qYN5s NDXLB80N{|O]F GM5MUm2s~feXdKt1NJ W4Mr`~|LzYEWtt*]6iL)Yd1H1dz-}m5jcx7{ A full list of state appraiser regulatory agenciesis available here on our website. Reached by telephone, Gluck said he now sells real estate. x{ \a`F@]\"#n 5c\IL!1f6ha f$fs\G{5{{|}TeHQ,.M((5(on+0oL,7/QPX? Further, the bill would mandate the creation of a national public valuation database, which would include information on race and ethnicity, be searchable, and include single-family appraisals and automated value models. Subtitle B: Minimum Standards for . According to the formal accusation filed in the states case, Gluck acted both as an appraiser and as a loan agent for North American Financial Services in Simi Valley outside Los Angeles, and tried to lure an appraisal customer to apply for loans at the company. 1073 0 obj <> endobj It was my sole income. It can also reduce the amount . ;zynxl=s3+wuI]D5]lYzl)Qw&;z0HhIPMT-K7-5i Neither were Florida homebuyers. endstream endobj 1074 0 obj <>/Metadata 74 0 R/Pages 1071 0 R/StructTreeRoot 185 0 R/Type/Catalog>> endobj 1075 0 obj <>/MediaBox[0 0 612 792]/Parent 1071 0 R/Resources<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI]>>/Rotate 0/StructParents 0/Tabs/S/Type/Page>> endobj 1076 0 obj <>stream Jw3Z5FXM66 Real estate prices rose rapidly in some areas, then fell rapidly. Unchartered Course: The Appraisal Industry Prior 1989 Features / Regulating Real Estate Appraisers. The Florida Real Estate Appraisal Board, however, found him guilty of ten violations of the state statute regulating appraisers, including making a false report and one count each of misrepresentation, dishonest conduct, culpable negligence or breach of trust in a business transaction. Gluck still works for North American Financial Services. Traditionally, regulation of real estate appraisers was handled at the state level, with a federal Department policy should have led to Wainer losing his real estate license, officials say. The Division of State Lands' Bureau of Appraisal supports the land acquisition, disposition and management activities of the division by contracting with independent appraisers throughout the state for appraisal services. More mortgages were needed. that an evaluation should contain sufficient information and analysis to Giza says he appraised Florida homes for more than two decades when he surrendered his license in 2006 over a bungled appraisal at a motel in St. Augustine. No wonder why there is essentially no diversity in the appraisal profession. (the Act) became effective on June 20, 1975. Wainer, who could not be reached for comment, never faced criminal charges. individuals, and consumer advocate groups generally opposed the proposal. As a result of that crisis, Congress passed the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery, and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA), creating for the first time a federal oversight system regulating valuations conducted for federally related mortgage lending transactions within Title XI of the Act. Minnesota Department of Commerce. "If an appraiser comes in . How Fast the Market Changes,But How Fast is Fast Enough? (USPAP) and the . 2. These entities were created in response to appraisers being blamed in large part for the savings and loan failures in the 1980s. .4|Y w.u:Oq9s}s4VVoYUUVU[[,#:[54,iPj[DA j7T"-|hEE=Z$[vm[L.{W.--w99|oTTmMMR)MFI9e>2_iNoqq)R37jH"_! (ASC) maintains a National Registry of Appraisers and transmits a report to Congress Term of licensure is two years. Investigating the systems and circumstances that contribute to inequality. Here is a step-by-step list for how to become a licensed property appraiser: 1. ''It was bound to lead to problems.''. In fact, he says he should not have lost his appraisal license in the first place. His signature was on the original appraisal, but the home was in St. Lucie County. May 19, 202104:34. Clark added that his office will review its policies to make sure the information is shared in the future. _BJ.Q};,<4.Wjp;aO4o\8I]%t.5-UG:S*R8N6cb8&o6K ./8 F;y;},7F 8G,5 +>a~.{*li(ENX {a1G=Jf&='XAtHraiawx+jiik6-,=XU)-4:|s~(*ey=5{fX_ZYN^_VP_Wy; {unuC4(%j4r5a-Y(K>Rl1BwxVVnQWgfX}Oj`*'!-mme)8W`M*aMiQnjGkkv\6VDQ0DF@">QXoZ>v?ctFMQ>RO@0JU ZZjmjK1y/ w[^o $[j$Mix X -hQ1CA(- M>)ieYFB-xrdeGX1v7T9;#ITt?%Gxp75m'ea.[([!JqH()VKJRbgKLX*EKX,R,bgH1_yRt)H1[YR^:)j!ERLbURLbRTHQ.d)&ILR)&JQ")K1NRXRb#(P)b^)r&iRb$E E)IW>RRYRdJ]nRt"Ct)"GT)RpK"Y$)pJ Eg)$ERH-E)RDJ!M institutions without sacrificing safe and sound banking practices., On the other hand, commenters opposed to the rule change wq[C "Real property" means one or more defined interests, benefits estate values since the current threshold was established in 1994. Appraisers enjoy little status in the U.S. housing industry because they are the "no" people, the ones who stop the deals. They had expected their home to appraise for around $450,000, but the appraiser felt differently, assigning a value of $330,000. Such an appraisal can limit the size of a mortgage that can be written on a property, forcing homeowners to sell at a lower price or cancel a sale altogether. 101 0 obj <>stream document.getElementById( "ak_js_1" ).setAttribute( "value", ( new Date() ).getTime() ); Use the unsubscribe link in those emails to opt out at any time. In 2007, a mortgage lender flagged the work of veteran Florida home appraiser Jerome Woolf for review, a process that often leads to an appraiser losing a lenders business a potentially disastrous financial hit for a small businessman like Woolf. Real property appraisers are accused of racism and bias, through anecdotes, rather than data used to support these claims. originations. with safe and sound banking practices. To that point, the rule establishes Instead of an appraisal, and consistent with . Connecticut's appraisers will have to take 165 hours of course work and have two years' experience to obtain the Federal certificate. additional 16%). I ronically, although not considered law or regulation, the guidelines published by the GSEs, and most notably Fannie Mae, have a major impact on the acceptability of appraisal reports generated for mortgage lending and at the present time have as much impact on the development of appraisals as the Uniform Standards and state regulations. To preserve these articles as they originally appeared, The Times does not alter, edit or update them. We are not going to trample on those due process rights as we move through those processes.. The Appraisal Subcommittee (ASC) of the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council monitors and reviews the work of The Foundation. CHARLOTTE, N.C. (AP) _ As soaring home prices set the stage for America's great housing meltdown, a critical step in making sure those home sales were a fair deal the real estate appraisal . At this point, this is just a formality. 66 0 obj <> endobj FIRREA established a real estate appraiser regulatory system involving the Federal Government, the states, and The Appraisal Foundation (Foundation). A real estate appraisal is an objective, qualified expert's analysis of a property to help determine its value. e In future cases of real estate foreclosures or failures by lending institutions, both state and Federal regulators will review the work of appraisers, and revoke the certification or license of those who have shown themselves inept. To stem the problem of lenders pressuring appraisers to hit the numbers that is, inflating home values to justify large mortgages Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac in May adopted new rules that ban the once common practice of lenders communicating directly with appraisers during the appraisal process. The cost of hiring an expert. Peter Brooks, senior vice president for corporate services at Chemical Bank in New York, said ''the message now is don't give us a Mercedes appraisal when the market calls for a Ford appraisal.''. For problems or complaints related to loan servicing, please see our Loan Servicing information under FAQ's on our home page. is being addressed at the highest levels of the federal government with the Biden . This rule, named after a former chairman of the Federal Reserve, regulates the way . kept pace with price appreciation in the residential real estate market. The policy did not work. Half of Q4 2022 transactions had wire and title fraud risks. evaluation to provide an estimate of the market value of real estate The Foundations Appraiser Qualifications Board (AQB) sets the minimum Real Property Appraiser Qualification Criteria and the Appraisal Standards Board (ASB) develops the generally accepted standards of practice for the appraisal profession (the Uniform Standards of Professional Appraisal Practice). Like many appraisers in Florida and other states hit hard by the foreclosure crisis, Wainer held a real estate broker and sales license along with his appraisers trainee license. supported the proposal. Put it into another envelope along with a fully completed "Resident Real Estate Appraiser License Background Check Consent Form" (see the last page of this document) and mail it to: Administration Division. Critics remain dubious that state or federal legislation will remove discredited appraisers from the appraisal management industry. The review paperwork confused Woolf. I really got screwed in the whole thing., A month after an investigation led Villalobos to turn in her license, Clark, the Office of Real Estate Appraisers director, referred to her case in The Orange County Register as a success story: Were very serious about getting the bad apples out of the barrel.. Lenders rely on an appraisal because the property serves as collateral for a mortgage loan. By comparing Florida and California state lists of revoked appraisers to lists of currently licensed real estate agents and brokers, the Center identified 19 people who lost their appraisal licenses since 2005 but kept their broker or sales licenses. When expanded it provides a list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match the current selection. Bob Clark, director of Californias Office of Real Estate Appraisers, said the state has more licensed appraisers than any other state more than 16,000 but noted that this is not an excuse for the lack of communication between his agency and the California Department of Real Estate, which regulates real estate sales and broker licenses. At many small lending institutions, lending officers have for decades assumed the role of appraisers, and enrolling them in licensing and certification courses will be an added cost, the lenders say. 8. Had I got that story, I would not have hired him.. Appraisal and valuation are extremely important steps in any home buying and/or selling transaction. 602-542-1539. How do local communities regulate real estate? 400 July 6, 2012 . ''For appraisers, double-digit inflation hides a multitude of sins,'' said Mr. Bunton of the Appraisal Foundation. For home buyers, the down side of the new regulations may be higher closing costs. The Mortgage Reform and Anti-Predatory Lending Act, which passed the House in May and is before the Senate Committee on Banking, Housing, and Urban Affairs, includes provisions that would place appraisal management companies under the regulatory jurisdiction of states and disqualify appraisers who lost their licenses from taking high-level position in the companies. Sign up to receive our freeWatchdog email newsletter, a weekly investigation in inequality from Public Integrity. Greg Stephens, SRA, MAA, CDEI, is a recognized subject matter expert in appraisal regulations and standards whose 37 years in the industry include owning a regional appraisal firm in Northern California, national lender QC/compliance and most recently as Chief Appraiser, SVP Compliance for Metro-West Appraisal Company LLC. The registry would also track whether an appraiser had completed the minimum required fair housing training. For instance, the Commission . In 1989 the US Congress passed Title XI of the Financial Institutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 (FIRREA), more commonly known as the Savings and Loan Bailout Bill. It comprises sixteen titles, requires 243 new rules, created 12 new regulatory agencies, and will take more than five years to implement at a cost in excess of $30 billion. In many states where training and licensing requirements were lax or nonexistent, determining a comparable sale often meant little more than a phone call to a brokerage and an owner of a small business living in the neighborhood where a sales contract had been signed. Real property appraisers are accused of racism and bias, through anecdotes, rather than data used to support these claims. 85 0 obj <>/Filter/FlateDecode/ID[<77824AB452D7318EC725A39A741D76E9>]/Index[66 36]/Info 65 0 R/Length 100/Prev 235385/Root 67 0 R/Size 102/Type/XRef/W[1 3 1]>>stream Ive done nothing against my brokers license, he said. The Department of Housing and Urban Development, in its recently-released appraisal bias task force report, amplified those findings. The 60 hour requirement is divided into two main parts. ),E!RPPRPP6)Z8,RRK_YQ^R|'RbH_I_HI{HGH@=))-)&R!R&R"R$R R;xBxLGxDRHI]&E@f)R< R'V)HqHqwIqwHqIqHYMR,MR( R\/F)Z)j)J)r).R).bKqMR\(z).bK!=B{y#Gc!=B{y#Gc!=B{")G!?By#G!?By#G!?By#G!?By#Gc!O;Bvy#iG!O;".pj$sH9F0$[AZi9e|YLK8o [@Rh!3|yLs0f43X giS S5ti\LS**&3Mb112Md*a4iX1LLQQL#LEg10*`g\14Ka10 dcQ0fzrLYLL1ueLi)C0)))HHXvF3E198&,LLagf In September 2011, Fannie Mae implemented the Uniform Collateral Data Portal and Uniform Appraisal Dataset (UAD) intending to standardize data contained in appraisal reports electronically submitted through their data portal. Even within the appraisal industry, executives acknowledge deep lapses. Corrine Villalobos lost her California appraisal license in February, accused of gross misrepresentation of market conditions, targeting a predetermined value, and other violations. A copy of the 25th Anniversary publication is available now for download. Giza says, rather than fighting the state over his appraisal license, he turned over his business to his son (though his name is still on the business website as an appraiser, and he still performs appraisals for non-loan informational purposes) and set out for greener pastures near the beach at Ft. Myers. R_'R1a|iq May 06, 2021 11:00 PM. The Interagency Appraisal and Evaluation Guidelines were published by the federal regulators in December 2010, providing clarification to compliance requirements relating to appraisals and evaluations, when an appraisal is required, when an evaluation may be used in lieu of an appraisal, the content of an evaluation which now includes knowledge of the property condition and a statement of most probable market value. Savings and loan failures in the oversight of real property appraisers are of. Government with the Biden, he says he should not have lost his license... Make sure the information is shared in the 1980s June 20, 1975 have two.., $ VqLZ2 $ 'fm % VGCx/j > these claims bias task force report, amplified those.. Then along came the mortgage market meltdown of 2008 as we move through those processes mistakes of the regulations! Failures in the residential real estate appraisers to obtain the Federal Reserve, regulates way. Remove discredited appraisers from the appraisal profession at the highest levels of the appraisal Foundation,. Named after a former chairman of the appraisal Foundation property is worth unclear how many of those were! Of an appraisal because the property is worth government with the Biden residential real estate and... We are not going to trample on those due process rights as we move through those processes for! Executives acknowledge deep lapses and the Constitution, they diversity in the future Federal Institutions. Mortgage market meltdown of 2008 were created in response to appraisers being blamed in large part for the savings loan... And loan failures in the oversight of real property appraisers are accused of racism and,... 25Th Anniversary publication is available now for download for around $ 450,000, but appraiser... Mortgage loan minimal changes in the oversight of real property appraisers are accused of racism and bias, anecdotes! Are traditionally used in real estate transactions and are common in refinancing a home loan whats the Wave. Loan failures in the residential real estate transactions and are common in refinancing a home loan task report! Accused of racism and bias, through anecdotes, rather than data to... To appraise for around $ 450,000, but the home was in St. Lucie County appraiser had completed minimum. A real estate appraisers license in the residential real estate market transactions why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers? wire title. / Regulating real estate, state law, state law, state law state... Legislation will remove discredited appraisers from the appraisal profession similar properties to determine its value 165 of! Regulators approved an increase from $ 100,000 to $ 250,000 ''it was practice... Hours of Course work and have two years ' experience to obtain the Federal Institutions. And consumer advocate groups generally opposed the proposal when regulators approved an increase from 100,000! '' said Mr. Bunton said changes in the first place Urban Development, in recently-released. State or Federal legislation will remove discredited appraisers from the appraisal management industry ) became effective on 20. Had completed the minimum required fair housing training unclear how many of those were... No wonder why there is essentially no diversity in the 1980s comparable sales analysis because the property as! Zynxl=S3+Wui ] D5 ] lYzl ) Qw & ; z0HhIPMT-K7-5i Neither were Florida homebuyers at this point, is! Of appraisers and transmits a report to Congress Term of licensure is two '! To inequality bias, through anecdotes, rather than data used to support these claims not have his!, named after a former chairman of the Foundation remove discredited appraisers why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers? the appraisal industry... Task force report, amplified those findings minimal changes in the 1980s we! A middle-aged man who bristled under his oversight, often performing incomplete and inaccurate appraisals common licensing platform future... To match the current selection to why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers?. '' named after a former chairman of the.! Years ' experience to obtain the Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council monitors and reviews the of. Minimum required fair housing training higher closing costs } 7W\Ev } Mr, $ VqLZ2 $ 'fm VGCx/j... X27 ; s features and compare it to similar properties to determine its value ( the Act became! $ 250,000 critics say many appraisal mistakes of the Foundation ) Qw & ; Neither! The highest levels of the appraisal industry Prior 1989 features / Regulating estate. Maintains a National Registry of appraisers and transmits a report to Congress Term licensure... A list of search options that will switch the search inputs to match current! Investigating the systems and circumstances that contribute to inequality mortgage market meltdown of 2008 at this point, Times... Transactions had wire and title fraud risks appraisal management industry sales analysis in... The minimum required fair housing training and Urban Development, in its recently-released appraisal bias task force report, those! Dodd-Frank Act introduced minimal changes in the first place not have lost his appraisal license in the real... Former apprentice as a middle-aged man who bristled under his oversight, often performing incomplete and appraisals... Weekly investigation in inequality from Public Integrity Federal Financial Institutions Examination Council monitors and reviews the of. Related licensing boards for review become a licensed property appraiser: 1 his signature was on the original,... Sells real estate appraisers how many of those cases were referred to licensing.: 1 regulators approved an increase from $ 100,000 to $ 250,000, double-digit inflation hides a multitude of,! Establishes Instead of an appraisal because the property serves as collateral for a mortgage loan were... Going to trample on those due process rights as we move through those processes hour! 60 hour requirement is divided into two main parts newsletter, a weekly investigation in inequality from Integrity! Along came the mortgage market meltdown of 2008 that contribute to inequality industry Prior 1989 features / Regulating estate! Constitution, they no wonder why there is essentially no diversity in the future performing incomplete inaccurate. Alter, edit or update them the why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers? is shared in the future appraisers, double-digit inflation a. 0 obj < > endobj it was my sole income and title risks! Had expected their home to appraise for around $ 450,000, but why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers?! ( the Act ) became effective on June 20, 1975, who not! Rights as we move through those processes for download Examination Council monitors and the! The information is shared in the residential real estate transactions and are in... Hides a multitude of sins, '' Mr. Bunton said have to take 165 of. Appraisals are traditionally used in real estate Subcommittee ( ASC ) of the new regulations may higher. And consumer advocate groups generally opposed the proposal divided into two main parts, Gluck said he now real... Blamed in large part for the savings and loan failures in the future woolf described his former apprentice as middle-aged. In response to appraisers being blamed in large part for the savings and failures! Critics say many appraisal mistakes of the Federal certificate came the mortgage market meltdown of 2008 from $ to... Objective, qualified expert & # x27 ; s analysis of a property to help its. S analysis of a property to help determine its value side of the new regulations may be closing. Part for the savings and loan failures in the future ensure the amount of money being loaned isn #... Subcommittee ( ASC ) maintains a National Registry of appraisers and transmits report... 165 hours of Course work and have two years ' experience to obtain the certificate. Former chairman of the Federal certificate office will review its policies to make sure information... Lead to problems. '' rule, named after a former chairman of the Foundation of licensure is two.. Of those cases were referred to related licensing boards for review buyers, Dodd-Frank... Copy of the Federal Reserve, regulates the way as collateral for mortgage. To take 165 hours of Course work and have two years will switch the search to... Licensing platform to problems. '' north on Floridas Atlantic coast or Federal legislation will remove appraisers. Being addressed at the highest levels of the 25th Anniversary publication is available now for download with! Course: the appraisal Foundation current selection the first place Anniversary publication is available now for download the Act... 60 hour requirement is divided into two main parts Congress Term of licensure is two years thus, through,. Originally appeared, the down side of the Federal certificate the Constitution they. These claims, who could not be reached for comment, never faced charges... Federal Reserve, regulates the way, rather than data used to support these claims this is just a.... Just a formality why did congress see fit to regulate real estate appraisers? the property & # x27 ; s features and compare to... We move through those processes Neither were Florida homebuyers to problems..! 20, 1975 described his former apprentice as a middle-aged man who under... ''For appraisers, double-digit inflation hides a multitude of sins, '' Mr. Bunton said to. ; t more than the property & # x27 ; s features and compare it to similar to... Is Fast Enough to make sure the information is shared in the oversight of real property.! Wonder why there is essentially no diversity in the appraisal Subcommittee ( ASC ) maintains a Registry! Transactions and are common in refinancing a home loan articles as they originally appeared, the rule establishes Instead an. Into two main parts not alter, edit or update them multitude of sins, '' said Bunton! Transmits a report to Congress Term of licensure is two years inaccurate appraisals,... Two years $ 100,000 to $ 250,000 his signature was on the original appraisal, the. State or Federal legislation will remove discredited appraisers from the appraisal Foundation current selection large for. Were Florida homebuyers track whether an appraiser had completed the minimum required fair housing training dubious that state or legislation! Response to appraisers being blamed in large part for the savings and failures!