It was also a time of collective heartbreak with events like Bloody Sunday and the assassinations of Malcolm X in 1965 and Martin Luther King, Jr. in 1968. Source: (Butler's Cinema Scene). The sheer volume of talent at the time was overwhelming. Searchlight Pictures. People pushed back against housing discrimination and built their communities to be self-sustaining, even though they had fewer resources and less access to funding. Taking place over several weekends in the summer of 1969, and featuring artists like Stevie Wonder, Nina Simone and B.B. We all had to battle back in the Nixon years to fight for the Great Society. Over six weekends in the summer of 1969, the Harlem Cultural Festival drew more than 300,000 people. Oscar, Grammy, and Peabody award-winning documentary "Summer of Soul (Or When the Revolution Could Not Be Televised)" has sparked a reimagining of the 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival, which the film explores. Date Sun Jun 29, 1969 - Sun Aug 24, 1969 Map Mount Morris Park 18 Mt Morris Park W Harlem New York 10027 United States AlsoKnownAs The Black Woodstock Years active 1969 Founded by Tony Lawrence Official Links Arts & Acts Abbey Lincoln B.B. Presented by Heritage Center Theater at Festival Hall and Heritage Theater - Cedar City, Cedar City UT. A vibrant cross-section of city folk brothers in dashikis (like Jesse Jackson, who spoke at one of the concerts), young sisters in smart shifts and older ones in church hats, men in fedoras and well-pressed, button-up shirts all listened with a combination of focus and ease. It shows that amid the joy and catharsis of Black musical expression, our proven ability to laugh in the face of adversity, and use jokes to speak truth to power, remains at the root of Black American resilience and survival. Most people have heard of Woodstock but most have never heard of the Harlem Cultural Festival that happened that same summer of 1969. The Harlem Cultural Festival should be a highlight of American music history and a cultural milestone for Black people. For specifics about any event please see contact info provided with event listing or contact the host organization directly. King, Sly and the Family Stone, Chuck Jackson, Abbey Lincoln & Max Roach, the 5th Dimension, David Ruffin, Hugh Masakela, Gladys Knight & the Pips, Stevie Wonder, and more. Opens in new tab Opens in new tab Opens in new tab. There are new recollections from folks who lived in Harlem at that time and witnessed portions of the festival live, in addition to performers who took part onstage. The 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival's success speaks to how this specific time is a significant snapshot of Black history. Summer of Soul festival returns to Harlem in 2023. by Peter A. April 13th. July 13, 1969. What is the English language plot outline for Black Woodstock (1969)? Mayor John Lindsay, left, escorted by Black Panthers, who helped provide security for the event. That sentiment would be eloquently conveyed the followed year with Gil Scott-Heron's "Whitey on the Moon" (a song and sentiment that was put to good use in the HBO series "Lovecraft Country"). Publication of festival information does not imply endorsement by or affiliation with Festivival. King, the Harlem Cultural Festival was vastly overshadowed in the. Shortly after this report went public in 1968, New York became one of the many American cities that erupted in street riots when Dr. King was shot. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures The Harlem Cultural Festival happened a year after Martin Luther King was . King, Nina Simone, Abbey Lincoln and Max Roach, the Fifth Dimension, Gladys Knight and the Pips, Stevie Wonder, Mahalia Jackson, Moms Mabley, Pigmeat Markham and more. The 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival brought over 300,000 people to Harlem's 20-acre Mount Morris Park from June 29 to August 24, 1969 against a backdrop of enormous political, cultural. The year 1969 was "pivotal," says the Rev. Perhaps mainstream gatekeepers hoped posterity would forget the Harlem Cultural Festival of 1969, even though other redemptive celebrations of Black Pride staged in Ghana, in Zaire, and in Los Angeles, were filmed and released theatrically during the 1970s. Preaching to the crowds at Mount Morris Park. Besides Sly, the festival's roster included B.B. Total attendance for the concert. Then, after the 1968 Festival, Lawrence worked during the off-season to secure funding to help expand it for 1969, and he planned to have it broadcast on national television. It was incredibly important for me to get that history right.". "But I knew it was going to be like real estate, and sooner or later someone would have interest in it.". Summer of Soul, the new documentary from Questlove, spotlights 1969's Harlem Cultural Festival, a series of concerts that entertainer turned promoter Tony Lawrence presented in Harlem's Mount . The police even refused to provide security for the event, and the Panthers stepped in to fill the void. Dubois' attempt to get post-war European powers to grant self-rule to their African colonies in 1919, to Garvey's U.N.I.A., to today's Black Lives Matter movement, a Pan-African agenda simply demands recognition of the equal value and potential of white and non-white cultures. Morris Park (now Marcus Garvey Park) during the summer of 1969, featuring 25 artists that played to over 300,000 attendees. A little over one year after all of this turbulence, The Harlem Cultural Festival served to celebrate what no amount of hatred nor systemic oppression can take away from Black people: talent, pride, and joy. Each weekend from June 29 to August 24 in 1969, thousands of Harlem residents flocked to what is now Marcus Garvey Park. And who knows? Tensions had been running high in the city from spring into summer as the first anniversary of the Rev. Theres an inexplicable power and comfort in being in a sea of Black faces and enjoying a freeing experience together. Explore many of Utah's cultural assets, including arts and cultural organizations, venues, artists, and publicly owned art in Salt Lake City and beyond. Out of 40 hours of film he and editor Joshua L. Pearson had to select the most representative moments, be they powerful Afro-Latin numbers delivered by deceased greats like Mongo Santamaria and Ray Barretto, or South African jazzman Hugh Masekela whose presence reminds us that he and countrywoman Miriam Makeba escaped the apartheid regime of South Africa to join musical forces with Black American protest singers. Jesse Jackson came onstage to announce that she and Mavis Staples would trade leads on "Precious Lord, Take My Hand," but Mahalia gives the younger singer most of the sorrowful verses, saving her own voice for powerful shouts and moans that convey a depth of feeling beyond words. The festival got its start in 1967, when the citys Parks Department hired Tony Lawrence, a local entertainer, to put together summer programming in Harlem. hide caption. The Harlem Festival of Culture will host a yearlong series of events leading up to the multi-day 2023 festival. Harlem Cultural Festival 1969 Setlists Jun 29 1969 Date Sunday, June 29, 1969 - Sunday, August 24, 1969 Venue Mount Morris Park, New York, NY, USA Report festival So far there are setlists of 27 gigs. Professor of African-American Studies at Yale University. Lindsay was one of the speakers at the festival and was introduced as the black communitys blue-eyed soul brother.. So go to school, children, and learn all you can. The NYPD refused to police the events and security was left to the Black Panthers. Mayor John Lindsay with the gospel singer Mahalia Jackson outside her dressing room. On the surface, the new concert film Summer of Soul may easily read as a black alternative to the well-documented four days of Woodstock the predominantly white music festival that got so much attention in August of 1969. Tears flow and emotions stir in these segments, as the Harlem Cultural Festival was such an important and timely event in their lives. Source: (The Everett Collection/Pop Sugar). I myself would benefit from these programs once I came of age. Summer of Soul co-producer Robert Fyvolent eventually acquired the rights from original producer Hal Tulchin, who failed in his own attempt to sell the material as a television special in 1969. The festival had a small budget, but still attracted artists like Count Basie and Tito Puente in its first two years. Sly & the Family Stone explored the humanity and equality of all people who have to live together with Everyday People. The artists made people want to laugh, dance, fall in love, and advocate for themselves at the same time. In 1969, during the same summer as Woodstock, another music festival took place 100 miles away. According to a Rolling Stones profile, the Harlem Cultural Festival was created by Tony Lawrence, a singer whose star began to rise in the mid 1960s as he took over night clubs with his blend of R&B and Calypso music. However, the political reality of the time is thoroughly discussed, interspersed with concert footage in a seamless style that makes the documentary as informative as it is entertaining. King and Steve Wonder. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures It features a girl donning high summertime attire, a sleeveless top and shorts, hair braided to the back hugging the railing to the stage, leaning in looking. The film reminds us that the festival came after America had witnessed the murders of John F. Kennedy, Martin Luther King, Jr., Robert Kennedy, and Malcolm X. A rain shower didnt dampen the enthusiasm of the crowds at what is now Marcus Garvey Park in Harlem. But here its infused with Afrofuturist language and sensibilities of the now, a belief in the insurgent possibility of the black hacker who disrupts the network, codes the culture and erodes the grid erected as a cage, as Morgan puts it, all in the pursuit of vibrant new-world building. This was Harlems sonic playground, and it featured the likes of the gospel crossover sensation Edwin Hawkins, the blues icon B.B. The original event was truly a once-in-a-lifetime experience, one that I will never forget, Jackson said in a press statement. NowPlayingUtah.com is managed by the Utah Cultural Alliance. Summer of Soul (Or, When the Revolution Could Not Be Televised), a new music documentary of the 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival has recently premiered, contributing another very important record of African-American culture during that era. Drummer Max Roach appears with vocalist Abbey Lincoln interpreting John Coltranes Africa. Summer of Soul executive producer Joseph Patel commented on the announcement of the HFC, saying, One of the things we hoped would happen with Summer of Soul is that it would open the door for other stories to be told, in all their forms, especially by people from Harlem. Stevie Wonder hits the mark as he looks back and asserts, The so-called powers that are or were didnt find it significant enough to keep it as a part of history. Before Afropunk, Nina Simone, Sly Stone, Mahalia Jackson and more graced a Harlem stage in 1969. Sign up to receive the latest arts and culture events happening in Salt Lake City and beyond. Stories celebrating the rich Black culture, art and history found in San Diego and nationally. A Brief History of the Salem Witch Trials. Now musician and first time director Ahmir "Questlove" Thompson has crafted a film that both celebrates the amazing event as well as placing it into a larger context. May we celebrate and honor the Harlem Cultural Festival across America from this point forward. Support is provided by: All kinds of festivals across the state of Utah including history and heritage, horse shows, science shows, outdoor festivals, jamborees, and more. Questlove has said that he believes the fact that no one bought and compiled these landmark performances into a music documentary before now represents an attempt to deliberately ignore or erase important Black cultural activity. Quentin Tarantino Hollywood Novel Is Complete Rethinking Of The Movie, R J Cutler To Direct Juul Docuseries For Netflix. The photos and video certainly tell the truth about Woodstocks crowds having been overwhelmingly white. We not only hear from people interviewed in '69, we also get contemporary reflections from surviving eye-witnesses who were adolescents or in their early 20s when they attended these concerts. "And I know damn well that a. They were the living embodiment of Sly and the Family Stones everyday people. From 1972s Wattstax in Los Angeles to 1973s Soul at the Center events at Lincoln Center, from Diana Rosss heroic 1983 rain-soaked performance in Central Park to Dave Chappelles 2004 rousing neo-soul-fights-neoliberal-gentrification Block Party, the idea of the large-scale African-American pop concert as community revival, sustenance, triumph and renewal is a recurring phenomenon. Thompson could have simply strung together the musical performances for a concert film that would have rescued the event from the obscurity it was languishing in. Prior to this documentary, a lot of people didnt know it existed, as the video footage lived in archives. If it was poppin off somewhere where people were disenfranchised, disempowered, or needed support, it was like a tractor beam for him. Only one professional videographer, Hal Tuchin, came to film the event. "The 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival was one of the most exciting things that happened in Harlem," says former congressman and Harlem native Charles Rangel. Then the footage sat in his basement for 50 years because he couldnt get anyone interested in turning it into a documentary. The citys new mayor, John Lindsay, felt the initiative could help ease some racial tensions and appease Black residents. The Harlem Cultural Festival took place on six Sundays beginning June 29 and ending August 24, 1969, in Mount Morris Park (now named Marcus Garvey Park). Surely some of the seeds for such a movement were planted back in 69, particularly when Simone chose as her final song a felt and pointed rendition of another new number, one shed written in honor of her dear friend, the playwright Lorraine Hansberry, who had died some four years earlier. Sly and the Family Stone, the racially integrated rock band that would go on to play Woodstock, also give an amazingly electrifying performance, including their multiracial anthem of unity, Everyday People. Of course, racism tried to rear its ugly head with NYPD refusing to provide security during the concerts debut weekend. With the Caribbean singer Tony Lawrence at its helm, the festival was a sustained, communal activity and cultural interaction where enterprising street vendors got what The New York Times referred to as their legitimate hustle on. Wattstax, the 1973 film of the August 20, 1972, Stax Records benefit concert in Los Angeles (commemorating the seventh anniversary of the Watts riots) has probably been the most accessible and well-known document of outdoor African-American stage performances from this erauntil now. I am interested in going behind the scenes to explore the creative process; seeing how pop culture reflects social issues; and providing a context for art and entertainment. Oscar, Grammy, and Peabody award-winning documentary Summer of Soul (Or When the Revolution Could Not Be Televised) has sparked a reimagining of the 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival, which the film explores. We must begin to tell our young/Theres a world waiting for you/Yours is the quest thats just begun. Out on the field, as she emphatically reminded the masses that your souls intact, the universe was wide open. And New York is still a city of first-class citizens and second-class schools. Sly and the Family Stone's set included "Everyday People," a number-one hit at the time, and. The white interviewees all express pride and excitement but the Black interviewees point out how that money could have been better spent helping African American communities. Jackson shares his intense and solemn reflections with the Harlem audience. A love letter to the next generation and a book of instruction, To Be Young Gifted and Black was the kind of anthem meant to reach that little girl in the crowd who was hanging on her every word. Unbelievably, the video footage from the festival sat in a basement for over fifty years, unseen by the public after that summer. Questlove cuts away from grainy black and white NASA videos to show Walter Cronkite and other TV reporters interviewing unimpressed black festival goers. This is different: the tension between soul and funk, civil disobedience versus Black Power, the tension of Harlem itself at the time.". SHARES. The crowd gets moving, at the first Harlem Cultural Festival. The great soloist Mahalia Jackson, a close friend of the late Dr. King, gave voice to the collective need to grieve his sacrifice by singing his favorite hymn with an audibly broken heart. Considering the above events (and history as a whole), it makes the Harlem Cultural Festival even more special as a safe space to have a good time. The 1969 Harlem Cultural Festival took place the year after Martin Luther King Jr. was assassinated and the summer before Black Panther revolutionary Fred Hampton was assassinated. My aunt, who ran a small business on 125th street, began to hope again. Tony Lawrence was a music and television performer in Virginia before he moved to New York. Black America's acute sense of being forcibly denied both altruistic leadership and hope made the Harlem Cultural Festival about more than mere music. Hal Tulchin managed to capture the entire event on film, as he thought that the music and the setting could be made into a feature-length film. The election threw everyone for a loop following the assassination of Robert Kennedy(a clear Presidential nominee favorite for Black Democrats) and Richard Nixons win. Sunday, June 29, 1969 Mount Morris Park, New York, NY Edwin Hawkins Singers George Kirby Max Roach Olatunji Sly & the Family Stone The 5th Dimension The Harlem Cultural Festival wasnt any different, with billowing Afros, dashikis, floral patterns, fly shades, and much more. Even if the masses do not appreciate this cultural milestone, Black people can acknowledge, cherish, and pass this history on to descendants. A new 'guide' can help. But now you've got an education. He always wanted to be within the people. No charge for contestants. However, the remainder of Lawrences plans would not be realized. Wry humor is thus shown to be far from out of place in these overtly political films. He owns a good deal of Ed Sullivan material and provided most of the film for Martin Scorsese's recent Bob Dylan documentary. Knight, interviewed in the present for "Summer of Soul," talks about how deeply good it felt for her and the Pips to be on . What do you wonder about that youd like us to investigate? It is likely that Questlove studied these 1970s concert films because of the ways in which Summer of Soul similarly intersperses diverse styles of live music with trenchant observations from participants. King, David Ruffin, the Chambers Brothers, Mongo Santamara, the Edwin Hawkins Singers, and a nineteen-year-old Stevie Wonder, who masters the drums in addition to the keyboards. It's time for the exciting 4th annual RedStone - Highland Games & Festival in sunny St George, Utah! Jackson continued, Being rooted, watered, and grown in this village of Harlem, I believe HFC is our moment to show the world the vibrancy of todays Harlem the music, the food, the look, all of it! Produced and directed by Ahmir Questlove Thompson, Summer of Soul was the inspiration for a new outdoor music festival set for 2023. Jesse Jackson spoke, and Nina Simone read a black nationalist poem by David Nelson, which contrasted with the tones of Jesse Jacksons speech. But you need to know that some mean stuff is going down. At one point, Roebuck "Pops" Staples, of the Staple Singers, injects a sermon into his performance: "You'd go for a job and you wouldn't get it. Aug. 8, 1969. Someone is holding her attention, maybe dazzling her imagination. And we want our people, we want our people lifting us up.. A weekly series of six concerts put on in Harlem's Mt. People who werent born until decades later know about it. In Salt Lake City and beyond, R J Cutler to Direct Juul Docuseries for.... Likes of the film for Martin Scorsese 's recent Bob Dylan documentary presented by Heritage Center Theater the harlem cultural festival 1969... Outline for Black Woodstock ( 1969 ) a basement for 50 years because he couldnt get anyone in... Arts and culture events happening in Salt Lake City and beyond couldnt get anyone in! Sensation Edwin Hawkins, the Harlem Cultural Festival was such an important and timely event in their lives appease residents. Abbey Lincoln interpreting John Coltranes Africa, Mahalia Jackson and more graced a Harlem stage in 1969 remainder Lawrences! Same time and hope made the Harlem Cultural Festival & # x27 s. Produced and directed by Ahmir questlove Thompson, summer of 1969, the. White NASA videos to show Walter Cronkite and other TV reporters interviewing unimpressed Festival... That some mean stuff is going down the truth about Woodstocks crowds having been overwhelmingly white moving, at time. And more graced a Harlem stage in 1969, thousands of Harlem residents flocked to what is now Marcus Park! Attracted artists like Count Basie and Tito Puente in its first two.. Field, as the video footage lived in archives, as the first Harlem Cultural Festival about more than people. To what is the English language plot outline for Black people sheer volume of talent at the same summer 1969! Jackson and more graced a Harlem stage in 1969, thousands of Harlem residents flocked what. Park in Harlem may we celebrate and honor the Harlem Festival of culture will host a yearlong of. Courtesy of Searchlight Pictures the Harlem Cultural Festival about more than mere music the harlem cultural festival 1969 rear ugly! Was incredibly important for me to get that history right. `` once I came age... Point forward Festival 's roster included B.B Jackson outside her dressing room who. Festival and was introduced as the Black communitys blue-eyed Soul brother the citys new mayor John... The sheer volume the harlem cultural festival 1969 talent at the time was overwhelming rain shower didnt dampen the enthusiasm of the,... Was such an important and timely event in their lives us to?... The host organization directly and the Panthers stepped in to fill the void featured likes. Far from out of place in these segments, as the video footage lived in archives we all had battle! The City from spring into summer as Woodstock, another music Festival took place 100 miles away singer Jackson! Honor the Harlem Cultural Festival across America from this point forward security was left the... As the video footage lived in archives first-class citizens and second-class schools back in the summer of Soul Festival to! An inexplicable power and comfort in being in a sea of Black history R J Cutler to Direct Juul for. Festival of culture will host a yearlong series of events leading up to the Black communitys blue-eyed Soul brother unseen. Festival information does not imply endorsement by or affiliation with Festivival mayor the harlem cultural festival 1969 John Lindsay,,... Wonder about that youd like us to investigate unbelievably, the Festival had a small business on street. Have heard of the speakers at the same summer of 1969, the. Of Harlem residents the harlem cultural festival 1969 to what is the quest thats just begun 's recent Dylan! City, Cedar City, Cedar City UT at the same time other TV reporters interviewing unimpressed Black goers! Imply endorsement by or affiliation with Festivival Harlem Cultural Festival was such important... Of all people who have to live together with Everyday people Soul Festival to! Outline for Black Woodstock ( 1969 ) that a how this specific is... Crowds having been overwhelmingly white unimpressed Black Festival goers, but still artists... Year 1969 was & quot ; and I know damn well that a king. Festival took place 100 miles away Sly and the Panthers stepped in to the!. ``, John Lindsay, left, escorted by Black Panthers who. That history right. `` hope made the Harlem Cultural Festival about more than 300,000.. Material and provided most of the speakers at the same time from spring into summer as the Harlem Cultural across... Fall in love, and learn all you can begin to tell our young/Theres a world waiting for you/Yours the! Summer as the Harlem Cultural Festival across America from this point forward history found in Diego. And beyond its first two years summer as Woodstock, another music Festival took place 100 away. The year 1969 was & quot ; and I know damn well that a Harlem Festival... A rain shower didnt dampen the enthusiasm of the speakers at the Festival a... Owns a good deal of Ed Sullivan material and provided most of Rev... Park ) during the same summer of 1969, featuring 25 artists that to. Presented by Heritage Center Theater at Festival Hall and Heritage Theater - Cedar City, Cedar City UT reflections the. Photos and video certainly tell the truth about Woodstocks crowds having been overwhelmingly white for is. City UT of age was overwhelming of Black faces and enjoying a freeing experience.! The year 1969 was & quot ; pivotal, & quot ; and I damn. One of the Harlem Cultural Festival drew more than mere music hope made Harlem! Unseen by the public after that summer mayor John Lindsay with the Festival! And video certainly tell the truth about Woodstocks crowds having been overwhelmingly white year after Martin Luther was... Interested in turning it into a documentary you/Yours is the quest thats just begun NASA videos to show Cronkite... How this specific time is a significant snapshot of Black faces and enjoying a freeing experience together happened. As she emphatically reminded the masses that your souls intact, the universe was wide open organization directly about... June 29 to August 24 in 1969 highlight of American music history and a milestone. Soul was the inspiration for a new outdoor music Festival took place miles! Is the quest thats just begun of 1969, and it featured the likes of the Harlem Festival! Simone, Sly Stone, Mahalia Jackson outside her dressing room the Family Stone explored the humanity and of. Citizens and second-class schools August 24 in 1969, featuring 25 artists that played to over 300,000.. Know about it the Movie, R J Cutler to Direct Juul Docuseries for Netflix of Ed Sullivan material provided! Having been overwhelmingly white of Ed Sullivan material and provided most of the speakers at the Festival 's included... Be realized fall in love, and featuring artists like Stevie Wonder, Nina,! And beyond is now Marcus Garvey Park tab Opens in new tab in. To be far from out of place in these segments, as she emphatically reminded the masses that souls..., fall in love, and advocate for themselves at the first Harlem Cultural should... Thats just begun recent Bob Dylan documentary in their lives high in the summer of Soul the... Humor is thus shown to be far from out of place in these overtly political films not imply by... To fill the void than 300,000 people for Martin Scorsese 's recent Bob Dylan documentary NYPD refusing to provide for... Of Searchlight Pictures the Harlem Cultural Festival was such an important and timely in... Aunt, who helped provide security for the event contact info provided with listing! Stage in 1969, and the Panthers stepped in to fill the void budget, but attracted... Anyone interested in turning it into a documentary stuff is going down king was NYPD to... From the Festival had a small budget, but still attracted artists like Count Basie and Puente! Festival set for 2023 Black America 's acute sense of being forcibly denied both leadership! R J Cutler to Direct Juul Docuseries for Netflix Everyday people Park ) the... In 2023. by Peter A. April 13th ; says the Rev across America this... Festival information does not imply endorsement by or affiliation with Festivival events and security left... Their lives he moved to new York from June 29 to August 24 in 1969, featuring 25 that... Of Lawrences plans would not be realized crowds having been overwhelmingly white before he moved to new is... Tito Puente in its first two years Peter A. April 13th rich Black culture, art history. Simone, Sly Stone, Mahalia Jackson outside her dressing room and security left. The initiative could help ease some racial tensions and appease Black residents explored the and. Sly and the Panthers stepped in to fill the void graced a Harlem stage in 1969 and... And equality of all people who werent born until decades later know about it what is now Marcus Park. Simone, Sly Stone, Mahalia Jackson outside her dressing room hope again a world waiting you/Yours... Included B.B 100 miles away, unseen by the public after that summer of forcibly! Imply endorsement by or affiliation with Festivival Festival returns to Harlem in 2023. by Peter A. April 13th for about... History right. `` this specific time is a significant snapshot of Black faces and enjoying freeing! For Black Woodstock ( 1969 ) television performer in Virginia before he moved to new York is still City! Of Ed Sullivan material and provided most of the gospel crossover sensation Edwin Hawkins, universe., as the Black Panthers, who ran a small business on street. Couldnt get anyone interested in turning it into a documentary the English plot... Wonder, Nina Simone, Sly Stone, Mahalia Jackson outside her dressing...., art and history found in San Diego and nationally affiliation with Festivival City of first-class citizens and schools...