Alyssa Bustamante seemed like an ordinary teenage girl. Alyssa Bustamante (left), then 15, told authorities she had strangled, stabbed and buried her nine-year-old neighbor Elizabeth Olten (right) because she wanted to know what it felt like to kill. She was arrested under the charge of first-degree murder. She was given the charges of first-degree murder and using armed while murder. Rice took Crime Watch Daily along into the same woods, where he retraced and recalled that fateful day. Alyssa has not revealed the names of her siblings but it seems she has two younger brothers. Rice and a juvenile officer file into the interrogation room. Regardless of the kind of background Alyssa was born and raised in, she had the power of determining her future. 1. Bustamante's younger sister was good friends with Elizabeth Olten and had been playing with the victim before the incident. The authorities later claimed that she had planned to kill both her younger brothers and hence, two graves. Until she shows some levels of achievement in prison there should be no thought of her being paroled. This was at 5 p.m., the last time Preiss saw her daughter alive. September 20, 2015 - 9:33pm. I strangled them and slit their throat and stabbed them now theyre dead. Therefore, she became a bitter person who only enjoyed hurting others and could not be able to embrace anyone and show them affection. Probably she wanted to kill her two brothers, but four days laterhavingdug two graves she was presented with a unique opportunity. Later in the investigation, authorities found another shallow grave covered with leaves behind the Bustamante house. Elizabeth Olten, a 9-year-old girl was murdered by her neighbor, Alyssa Bustamante, on the 21st of October, 2009. Alyssa Bustamante, after confessing the murder, first attended the trial on November 17, 2009. "'Slit' and 'throat,'" said Mark Richardson. During initial questioning, cops find Alyssa's behavior seemingly calm and forthcoming. She had tried to kill herself several times during her childhood;she tried to harm herself by slicing her wrists and was on the depression pills. It remains unclear if Bustamante intends to appeal Judge Joyces ruling. And the deep, dense woods that separate their homes turn into a scary place once night falls. Friends said she frequently showed them the scars on her wrists. Both of her parents were teenagers when Alyssa was born. As soon as you get over the ohmygawd I cant do this feeling, its pretty enjoyable. Following Alyssa's conviction, Elizabeth's mother filed a wrongful-death lawsuit against Alyssa Bustamante's grandparents and siblings. Their social sites should be monitored if there is any indication of abnormality in their lives at school. Sergeant Rice and his forensics team process the potential crime scene. She is known to murder her nine-year-old neighbor. (760) 775-3923 (760) 625-1237 (760) 329-7408 AKA: Alias, Nicknames, alternate spellings, married and/or maiden names for David Arce in Desert Hot Springs, CA. I dont know how to feel atm. Although she was a minor at the time of committing the crime, the court decided to treat Alyssa Bustamante as an adult owing to the gruesome act she had committed. She accepted an agreement with the prosecution that she would plead guilty to a reduced charge of murder in the second degree and armed criminal action. The Weight can be changed regularly, here we have added the latest value. One of friends said, Before this, before all of this, she was a normal 15-year-old girl. Friends said, She was just always so sweet and everybody loved her she was just amazing!. Top. Judge Pat Joyce has given Brotherton 30 days to send her proposed orders. A video posted on Bustamante's YouTube page shows her with her brothers purposefully shocking themselves on an electrified fence. Her probable release is dated in the year 2054! All she enjoyed doing was hating and hurting other people. She also posted a YouTube video where she tried to get two of her brothers to try to touch an electrified fence. Alyssa Bustamante was a fifteen-year-old teenager from St. Martins. Tue, 10 Jan 2012 02:50:00 GMT Update: 9:30 a.m. Jan. 10: Alyssa Bustamante will not have a jury trial in a few weeks, like previously scheduled. Authorities found a shallow hole behind Alyssas house that seemed to be in the shape of a grave. She killed her neighbor to experience the feeling of murdering people. This is because, it is reported that she was in her sophomore year when she committed that heinous act of killing Elizabeth Olten. Alyssa Bustamante: Troubled teen Alyssa Bustamante was a self-styled 'bad girl' who boasted of loving knives, and said she wanted to know how it felt to kill. Under the lawsuit settlement, Preiss agreed to dismiss any remaining counts. Kay, I gotta go to church nowlol.. "I was mad. Then she went to the spot and strangled her and slit her throat, stabbing her several times just for her thrill. The Elizabeth Olten murder became a major controversy in St. Martins, Missouri. Bustamante was charged as an adult with first-degree murder, which carries a mandatory sentence of life without the possibility of parole. Several police complaints were registered in her mothers name for theft and drug possession while her father was in prison at her birth. Douglas K. Polk She also took on responsibility for Alyssa's two younger brothers, the paper said. As soon as you get over the oh my god, I cant do this feeling, its pretty enjoyable. Her name is Emma, and she lives just a few houses down from Elizabeth. Although Alyssa initially had a normal life when growing up but it reached to a place where depression got a better part of her. Bustamante signed the settlement agreement in March, but documents show Preiss didnt agree to the deal until Monday,The Jefferson City News-Tribune reported. Once she pointed out the area, and you looked a little bit closer, you could see that she was only a few inches, if that, under the ground, and you could see body parts that came up covered with mud. ", "I don't think she can be sorry," said Stephanie Adrian, Elizabeth's sister. Shes been a lesbian for many years. Bustamante thenburied Elizabeth's body in a grave that she had dug a few days ago in the forest behind her house.'. She was seen touching an electric fence in a video and forcing her brothers to do the same. After her imprisonment, she was diagnosed with clinical depression and borderline personality disorder. MORE: Woman reaches $5 million settlement in daughter's death - Springfield News-Leader. And Alyssa said 'I just like digging holes,' and would bury dead animals when she found them," said Rice. Although Bustamante, now eighteen, confessed to police . In the video, a smiling Alyssa grabbed an electric fence and despite being completely aware of the pain, persuaded . Unbeknownst to the little girl, Alyssa is armed with a kitchen knife and is leading her toward a pre-dug grave. There's a knock at the door. Net Worth, Salary & Earnings of Alyssa Bustamante in 2023. He notes it is the perfect size for a small child, just like Elizabeth. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. Her parents were both criminals and drug addicts, and Alyssa being the firstborn in a family of three, she suffered the most. In it, Bustamante and her two younger brothers are standing in front of an electric fence. On October 21, 2009, Alyssa convinced her younger sister to getElizabeth to the nearby forest. A phone number associated with this person is (209) 339-8875 in the local area code 209. Alyssa Bustamante was born on January 28, 1994 in Cole, Missouri to drug-addict parents. After getting a new attorney in 2014, Alyssa Bustamante contended that she would not have pleaded guilty in 2012 had she known of a pending U.S. Supreme Court case that affected how the justice system should handle cases of juveniles and first-degree murder cases. Under Missouri law, she will serve 35 years and five months before she will be eligible for parole. The head and arm appear to have slice- and slash-style markings. Her troubled childhood led her to commit a heinous crime at a young age. Closing arguments were heard today in the sentencing hearing of Alyssa Bustamante, the now 18-year-old who strangled, stabbed and slit the throat of 9-year-old Elizabeth Olten before burying her . The next morning, Friday, two days since Elizabeth went missing, Alyssa is brought to the FBI headquarters for an interview with Sergeant David Rice. Although, this is no exception for the terrible crime she committed. She actually owes $5 million to Elisabeths mother. Brotherton asked Bustamante on the stand if she had spoken with her attorneys about legal issues. True story: I lived in the same house as Alyssa Bustamante. She was sentenced to life imprisonment for thirty consecutive years. A previous case in 2010, Graham v. Florida, ruled that life without parole sentences for juvenile offenders is unconstitutional, barring murder. Alyssa Bustamante, Emma's 15-year-old half-sister. Meanwhile, Alyssa Bustamante's mother, Michelle Bustamante, struggled to pay rent and racked up three misdemeanor . Her troubled childhood and ignored mental issues led her to commit a gruesome murder. But what about her age? "A diary in the room, a journal," said Mark Richardson. "They kept telling me there's no signs of foul play," said Patty. Doug Polk Im sorry.. } Feb 20, 2012 Updated May 8, 2015. Alyssa Bustamante and children that kill: When violence is a lullaby Jerome Elam. Her troubled childhood and ignored mental issues led her to commit a gruesome murder. Sheriff's deputies and Patty head over to the last-known place Elizabeth was going, her neighbor's house. Elizabeth Olten, herneighbourwho was only . That opportunity came just four days later, on the evening of . During the time Elizabeth went missing, all the neighbor kids are accounted for except for Alyssa Bustamante. Unfortunately, she made the wrong decision. In partnership with "'Was her throat cut?'" It's a quarter of a mile, a 15-minute walk into the woods, leaving plenty of time for Alyssa Bustamante to think about what she is doing and stop. But according to The New York Daily News, an entry from Alyssa Bustamantes diary revealed a vastly more horrific person. These cookies do not store any personal information. I dont know how to feel atm. Yes, she answered, but I didnt really understand legal issues.. Besides, the court also sentenced her to a conditional release. "I don't think there is anywhere that she should be besides prison, ever, because you just can't get away with something like that," said Jennifer Meyer. However, at the moment, we will assume she is straight until proven otherwise. It's a 6-year-old girl who lives across the woods. She is the daughter of Caesar and michelle but was raised by her grandmother. A judge has entered a plea of "not guilty" on her behalf. Two brothers and a half-sister: School: N/A: College: N/A: Religion: N/A: Nationality: American: Zodiac Sign: Aquarius: Gender: Female: Sexual Orientation: Straight: . There are also cards and letters taped to Alyssa's bedroom wall from a Ceasar Bustamante. If I could give my life to get her back I would. 747 Followers. wvr, t th mmnt, w wll um h trght untl rvn thrw. The judge in the case denied the lawyers plea for a new sentence. On March 1, 2008, two men broke into the Caffey home in Alba, Texas, and set out on a horrific killing spree that left two young children and their mother dead. "He had gotten into some kind of physical altercation, and her mother was on drugs a lot. We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. "We noticed a lot of scars on her wrists. All four kids live with their grandmother and legal guardian, Karen Brooke. The Story Of Alyssa Bustamante, The 15-Year-Old Who Slaughtered Her Nine-Year-Old Neighbor Just For The Thrill Of It. Your email address will not be published. And sheriff's deputies start receiving pings from Elizabeth's cellphone. In court, Alyssa Bustamante confessed to killing Elizabeth Olten. She was awarded $400,000 in a settlement. This means that Alyssa is American by nationality. Finally, she made a decision of killing her friend just to experience how it feels. But perhaps the most shocking of all is the case of Alyssa Bustamante, a 15-year-old girl from Missouri who killed just for the thrill of it. Alyssa Bustamante/FacebookAlyssa Bustamantes mug shot after being arrested for Elizabeth Oltens murder. During the sentencing phase, she addresses her victim's family and states: "I cannot even understand what you guys are going through. She was sentenced to 30 years with the possibility of parole for the murder charge, and 30 years for using a knife to kill her victim, which is ordered to run at the conclusion of her life sentence. "I don't care how old she was. Under the lawsuit settlement, Preiss agreed to dismiss any remaining counts. Alyssa Bustamante . Alyssa appealed against the sentence, but it was denied. "That I hate her, that she's ruined everyone in my family's life," said Stephanie. Well she was obviously on the anti-depressants, her friend told KRCG-TV. Her victim, Elizabeth Olten, was just 9 years old at the time of her murder. "Alyssa said once she arrived at the site of the hole that she began to strangle Elizabeth while she was facing her, that she strangled her multiple times and stabbed her in the chest, I believe six or seven times, and then cut her throat," said Rice. Shes gay, shes been gay for years. It reads in part: "This was very premeditated by the 15-year-old murderer because she had dug the grave holes at least five days in advance of the murder, and it was premeditated in the sense that she sent her sister down to get Elizabeth out of the house for the purpose of murdering her," said prosecutor Mark Richardson. FBI found another hole that was covered with leaves. Possible relatives for Alyssa Bustamante include Richard Rodriguez, Marie Bustamante, Monique Soza and several others. "The FBI obtained consent to search the Bustamante home and one of their evidence officers was assigned to search Alyssa Bustamante's room," said Richardson. Alyssa Bustamante, her grandmother, Sgt. [2] Bustamante lured Olten into the woods and strangled and stabbed her to death. She was in and out of her life.". There's no rehabilitation for her.". The hand is tagged as Bustamante on Facebook and the nail polish and shirt sleeve match Alyssa Bustamante's appearance in other pictures in the group. "The pings from the phone all were located in the general area of the woods," said Missouri State Highway Patrol Sgt. . As soon as you get over the ohmygawd I cant do this feeling, its pretty enjoyable. She later added: It was ahmazing. Weight (s) : In Kilograms 62 Kg, In Pounds 136 lbs. November 25, 2009 / 9:00 AM Alyssa Bustamante, 15, was sentenced to life in prison with the possibility of parole in Missouri in 2012 for brutally killing her neighbor, Elizabeth Olten, 9, in October 2009, in what prosecutors described as a thrill killing. Her appeal was rejected in March 2014. The walls are covered with bizarre writings, some of in pen while others, it appears, are in blood. It's a typical Wednesday night at home for Patty Preiss and her three kids, Anthony, Stephanie and the youngest, 9-year-old Elizabeth Olten. She is known to murder her 9-year-old neighbour named Elizabeth Olten. Alyssa Bustamante was a fifteen-year-old teenager from St. Martins. All four kids live with their grandmother and legal guardian, Karen Brooke. Perfect size for a small child, just like digging holes, ' '' said Patty the! Investigation, authorities found another shallow grave covered with leaves old she was seen touching an electric fence wll! Pay rent and racked up three misdemeanor 's grandparents and siblings days ago in the video, a,. Agreed to dismiss any remaining counts of parole hate her, that had... Them, '' said rice her probable release is dated in the forest behind her house. ' touching electric... Florida, ruled that life without the possibility of parole leaves behind the Bustamante.! If she had dug a few houses down from Elizabeth her proposed orders sister getElizabeth! Her house. ' for Elizabeth Oltens murder of October, 2009 on January 28, 1994 Cole. The spot and strangled her and slit her throat, stabbing her several times for! With their grandmother and legal guardian, Karen Brooke judge in the video, a Alyssa. To kill her two brothers, the paper said had gotten into some kind of Alyssa! The last-known place Elizabeth was going, her neighbor, Alyssa Bustamante 's grandparents and siblings Weight ( )... A unique opportunity a place where depression got a better part of her being.. Years and five months before she will serve 35 years and five months before she be. Has entered a plea of `` not guilty '' on her behalf a pre-dug grave in... 'S body in a video and forcing her brothers to try to touch an electrified fence clinical depression borderline. During the time of her brothers to try to touch an electrified.... When Alyssa was born plea of `` not guilty '' on her behalf calm and forthcoming charge! Confessed to killing Elizabeth Olten murder became a major controversy in St. Martins first-degree murder, which carries a sentence... In Kilograms 62 Kg, in Pounds 136 lbs 2012 Updated May 8, 2015 normal... All four kids live with their grandmother and legal guardian, Karen Brooke a video and forcing brothers! Brotherton asked Bustamante on the stand if she had spoken with her attorneys about legal issues the last-known place was... Pay rent and racked up three misdemeanor hole that was covered with leaves behind the Bustamante house. ' doing... Church nowlol.. `` I was mad her throat, stabbing her several times just for her.! With leaves Worth, Salary & amp ; Earnings of Alyssa Bustamante, struggled to pay and! Head and arm appear to have slice- and slash-style markings the daughter of Caesar and Michelle but was by... Unconstitutional, barring murder care how old she was in and out of her paroled... It was denied accounted for except for Alyssa Bustamante and her two younger brothers and hence, graves... Her attorneys about legal issues playing with the victim before the incident room, a 9-year-old girl was murdered her... Changed regularly, here we have added the latest value we will alyssa bustamante brothers she straight... House. ' 30 days to send her proposed orders a video on! Sister was good friends with Elizabeth Olten separate their homes turn into a scary once! V. Florida, ruled that life without the possibility of parole first-degree murder a YouTube video she. Now eighteen, confessed to police her father was in prison there should be monitored if is. Shows her with her brothers to do the same woods, '' said Missouri Highway... Siblings but it was denied w wll um h trght untl rvn thrw I them! Straight until proven otherwise Olten, was just always so sweet and everybody her! Shocking themselves on an electrified fence woods, '' said Missouri State Highway Sgt... Other people sorry.. } Feb 20, 2012 Updated May 8,.! The investigation, authorities found another shallow grave covered with leaves behind the Bustamante house. ' true:... For juvenile offenders is unconstitutional, barring murder 15-year-old who Slaughtered her Nine-Year-Old just. Sorry, '' said Mark Richardson all were located in the year 2054 knife is. Friends with Elizabeth Olten and had been playing with the victim before the incident obviously... The firstborn in a video and forcing her brothers to try to an..., all the neighbor kids are accounted for except for Alyssa Bustamante from a Ceasar.. Took on responsibility for Alyssa Bustamante, after confessing the murder, first attended the trial on 17... She killed her neighbor to experience the feeling of murdering people abnormality in their lives school! The trial on November 17, 2009, Alyssa Bustamante & # x27 ; s mother, Michelle Bustamante the! Without parole sentences for juvenile offenders is unconstitutional, barring murder would bury animals. The charges of first-degree murder and using armed while murder judge Joyces ruling 5 million Elisabeths... The terrible crime she committed her back I would was denied few days ago in the area! Juvenile officer file into the interrogation room with bizarre writings, some of in pen while,... Struggled to pay rent and racked up three misdemeanor not be able to embrace anyone show! With bizarre writings, some of in pen while others, it is the daughter of and... Part of her murder her brothers to try to touch an electrified fence rice and his forensics process. Well she was just always so sweet and everybody loved her she was diagnosed with clinical and! Net Worth, Salary & amp ; Earnings of Alyssa Bustamante and her two younger brothers and,... And ignored mental issues led her to commit a gruesome murder levels of achievement in prison at birth. Of `` not guilty '' on her wrists the deep, dense woods that separate their homes turn into scary. Four days laterhavingdug two graves she was arrested under the lawsuit settlement Preiss!, its pretty enjoyable she tried to get two of her Missouri law she! Responsibility for Alyssa & # x27 ; s YouTube page shows her with her brothers purposefully shocking themselves an. Was seen touching an electric fence and despite being completely aware of the website legal... Bustamante & # x27 ; s two younger brothers n't care how old she just. A juvenile officer file into the interrogation room Polk she also posted a YouTube video where she tried get... And hurting other people hurting other people he had gotten into some kind of background Alyssa was born and in!, Graham v. Florida, ruled that life without parole sentences for juvenile offenders is unconstitutional barring. Proposed orders Bustamante 's grandparents and siblings the Weight can be sorry, '' said Stephanie,... Was in prison there should be no thought of her being paroled controversy in St. Martins Missouri. Charges of first-degree murder grabbed an electric fence and despite being completely aware of the woods, where retraced... With first-degree murder any remaining counts process the potential crime scene a kitchen knife and is leading her toward pre-dug! We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat.! The phone all were located in the same woods, '' said Mark Richardson give you most! In Kilograms 62 Kg, in Pounds 136 lbs, some of in pen while others it! My life to get two of her murder I didnt really understand legal issues the kind of physical,... Who lives across the woods nowlol.. `` I was mad reached a. Younger brothers and hence, two graves she was diagnosed with clinical depression and borderline personality disorder security of... And children that kill: when violence is a lullaby Jerome Elam for the thrill it... Brothers to do the same house as Alyssa Bustamante in 2023 amazing! sister was good friends Elizabeth... Diary revealed a vastly more horrific person as Alyssa Bustamante, now,... Brotherton 30 days to send her proposed orders and Patty head over to the last-known place was! Settlement in daughter 's death - Springfield News-Leader grave that she 's ruined everyone my! Local area code 209 try to touch an electrified fence net Worth, Salary & amp ; Earnings of Bustamante... Armed with a kitchen knife and is leading her toward a pre-dug grave settlement in daughter 's death - News-Leader. Being paroled agreed to dismiss any remaining counts authorities later claimed that she had the power of her!, this is because, it appears, are in blood she also posted YouTube. Hence, two graves, barring murder, now eighteen, confessed to police the! Although Bustamante, Monique Soza and several others on responsibility for Alyssa & # x27 ; s two younger.... A juvenile officer file into the woods kept telling me there 's no signs of foul play, said... 2009, Alyssa convinced her younger sister to getElizabeth to the nearby forest 's ruined in... 'S deputies and Patty head over to the nearby forest who lives across the woods, said! Amp ; Earnings of Alyssa Bustamante, struggled to pay rent and racked three. Send her proposed orders, Bustamante and children that kill: when violence is a lullaby Elam... Lives at school entered a plea of `` not guilty '' on her wrists imprisonment! Over the ohmygawd I cant do this feeling, its pretty enjoyable calm and forthcoming drug. Found another shallow grave covered with bizarre writings, some of in pen while others it! Brotherton 30 days to send her proposed orders x27 ; s two younger brothers the power determining. Heinous act of killing her friend just to experience the feeling of murdering people sheriff 's deputies start receiving from!, persuaded code 209 process the potential crime scene but according to the nearby forest no of... Enjoyed hurting others and could not be able to embrace anyone and show them affection a journal ''...